How to Spot a Cowboy Locksmith

Most locksmiths are straightforward tradespeople, but the trade does attract a few operators who rely on people being in a stressful, time-pressured situation.

Red flags on the phone

A refusal to give any indication of price, or a price that seems unusually low up front, are both worth being cautious about — genuine locksmiths can usually give a reasonable estimate before arriving.

Pricing tricks to watch for

Some rogue operators quote a low call-out fee, then claim the job is more complicated once they're on site and the door is already open, leaving you with little leverage to negotiate.

Unnecessary drilling

Drilling should be a last resort, not a default. If a locksmith reaches straight for a drill without attempting non-destructive entry first, that's worth questioning.

Checking credentials

A legitimate local locksmith should be comfortable giving you a landline or established contact number, and often has reviews you can check before they even arrive.

What a legitimate locksmith does

Quotes a clear price before starting, explains what they're doing and why, and only recommends replacement when it's genuinely needed rather than the most profitable option.